A Commentary on HerodotusMachine readable text


A Commentary on Herodotus
By W. W. How




Perseus Documents Collection Table of Contents



BOOK I

BOOK II

BOOK III

BOOK IV

BOOK V

BOOK VI

BOOK VII

BOOK VIII

BOOK IX


Funded by The Annenberg CPB/Project

BOOK IV

 

Ch. 2 [sect. 1]

dou/lous. The information in this chapter is better than the logic; Stein suggests with reason that it is a later addition.

The idea that the slaves were blind may be due to a mistaken etymology for some Scythian word for slave (Stein; cf. 86. 4 n.), and perhaps to the fact that blindness is common in South Russia. Blind slaves obviously would be useless, nor does H. explain why they were blinded.

fushth=ras. Pallas (Nachr. Mong. Vlk. i. 119) in the eighteenth century describes a similar operation among the Calmucks to induce obstinate cows to give milk.

qhle/wn i(/ppwn. The Greeks were early struck by the Northern use of mares' milk. Cf. Il. 13.5 Ἱππημολγῶν γλακτοφάγων, Ἀβίων τε δικαιοτάτων ἀνθρώπων. The Hippemolgi and the Abii were supposed to be nations, and credited with all the virtues of the noble savage; these vain imaginations are not found in H., but they lasted as late as Ammianus (fourth century A. D.): even Arrian says (Anab. iv. 1) they were αὐτόνομοι διὰ πενίαν καὶ δικαιότητα.