A Commentary on HerodotusMachine readable text


A Commentary on Herodotus
By W. W. How




Perseus Documents Collection Table of Contents



BOOK I

BOOK II

BOOK III

BOOK IV

BOOK V

BOOK VI

BOOK VII

BOOK VIII

BOOK IX


Funded by The Annenberg CPB/Project

 

Book 4

BOOK IV

[For the Σκυθικοὶ λόγοι cf. K. Neumann, Die Hellenen im Skythenlande (1855), and S. Reinach, Antiquits de Russie Mridionale (1891-2).]

This book falls into two parts, cc. 1-144 giving the account of Scythia and the Scythian expedition, cc. 145-205 the story of Cyrene. Except Book II, no part of H.'s narrative has so little to do with his main subject, while none is so rich in curious information, much of which is invaluable to the anthropologist. The account of the Scythians especially is important as the earliest study we possess of an uncivilized people. Nothing is more instruc[p. 303] tive, in estimating the difference between the points of view of H. and of Thucydides, than to compare the former's full-length study of the Scythians with the brief sketch of Macedonia and Thrace given by the latter (ii. 97; cf. 81. 1 n.); H. is the type of the earlier Greek, to whom all knowledge and all the world were of interest, Thucydides of the Periclean Athenian, who concentrated himself on the political affairs of Greece in the narrowest sense.



Ch. 1-4

The motives for Darius' campaign (for a discussion of these cf. App. XII. 3-4).



Ch. 1 [sect. 1]

au)tou=: emphatic; the king led in person. Cf. vii. 10 η. For the Scythian invasions cf. i. 104-6 nn., for the Cimmerian i. 15 nn.