Commentary on the Homeric HymnsMachine readable text


Commentary on the Homeric Hymns
By Thomas W. Allen
London Macmillan 1904



Perseus Documents Collection Table of Contents



THE HOMERIC HYMNS IN ANTIQUITY
   FIFTH CENTURY B.C.
   THIRD CENTURY B.C.
   FIRST CENTURY B.C.6
   SECOND CENTURY A.D.

THE NATURE OF THE HOMERIC HYMNS

HYMN TO DIONYSUS

HYMN TO DEMETER

HYMN TO APOLLO

HYMN TO HERMES

HYMN TO APHRODITE

HYMN TO APHRODITE

HYMN TO DIONYSUS

HYMN TO ARES

HYMN TO ARTEMIS

HYMN TO APHRODITE

HYMN TO ATHENA

HYMN TO HERA

HYMN TO DEMETER

HYMN TO THE MOTHER OF THE GODS

HYMN TO HERACLES THE LION-HEARTED

HYMN TO ASCLEPIUS

HYMN TO THE DIOSCURI

HYMN TO HERMES

HYMN TO PAN

HYMN TO HEPHAESTUS

HYMN TO APOLLO

HYMN TO POSEIDON

HYMN TO ZEUS

HYMN TO HESTIA

HYMN TO THE MUSES AND APOLLO

HYMN TO DIONYSUS

HYMN TO ARTEMIS

HYMN TO ATHENA

HYMN TO HESTIA

HYMN TO EARTH THE MOTHER OF ALL

HYMN TO HELIOS

HYMN TO SELENE

HYMN TO THE DIOSCURI

THE HOMERIC HYMNS IN ANTIQUITY
   FIFTH CENTURY B.C.
   THIRD CENTURY B.C.
   FIRST CENTURY B.C.6
   SECOND CENTURY A.D.

THE NATURE OF THE HOMERIC HYMNS

HYMN TO DIONYSUS

HYMN TO DEMETER

HYMN TO APOLLO

HYMN TO HERMES

HYMN TO APHRODITE

HYMN TO APHRODITE

HYMN TO DIONYSUS

HYMN TO ARES

HYMN TO ARTEMIS

HYMN TO APHRODITE

HYMN TO ATHENA

HYMN TO HERA

HYMN TO DEMETER

HYMN TO THE MOTHER OF THE GODS

HYMN TO HERACLES THE LION-HEARTED

HYMN TO ASCLEPIUS

HYMN TO THE DIOSCURI

HYMN TO HERMES

HYMN TO PAN

HYMN TO HEPHAESTUS

HYMN TO APOLLO

HYMN TO POSEIDON

HYMN TO ZEUS

HYMN TO HESTIA

HYMN TO THE MUSES AND APOLLO

HYMN TO DIONYSUS

HYMN TO ARTEMIS

HYMN TO ATHENA

HYMN TO HESTIA

HYMN TO EARTH THE MOTHER OF ALL

HYMN TO HELIOS

HYMN TO SELENE

HYMN TO THE DIOSCURI


Funded by The Annenberg CPB/Project

 


Poem 33

HYMN TO THE DIOSCURI

Although placed last in the collection, this hymn is no doubt older than xvii, which seems merely an abstract of it. The poem is a vigorous piece of writing, and may well belong to a period at least as early as the fourth or third century B.C. The reference to the Dioscuri as winged (13) seems a mark of lateness; on the other hand the hymn appears to be pre-Alexandrine, for there is little doubt that it was imitated by Theocritus,92 whose description of the storm lulled by the Dioscuri is more elaborate than the simple language of the hymn (idyl. xxii, see on 6, 15).

In this hymn, as often, the Twin Brethren are identified with the lights (of an electric nature) which appear on the masts or sails of a ship during a storm; cf. Eur. Or. 1636 f.; Plin. N. H. ii. 101, Diod. iv. 43, Plut. de def. or. 30; Lucian dial. deor. xxvi. 2: Seneca Q. N. 1. 1. 13; Ov. Fast. v. 720. Two lights were a sign of safety; a single light (identified with Helen = ἑλέναυς) betokened the worst. From the middle ages the lights have been called the fire of Elmo St.(Telmo). Frazer on Paus. ii. 1. 9 gives references for the mediaeval and modern belief.

The editors do not notice the similarities of language between this hymn and vii (to Dionysus); cf. 1 (ἀμφί) = vii. 1; 8 ἀπὸ νηῶν = vii. 6 ἀπὸ νηός (a rare use); 12 ἐφάνησαν = vii. 2 ἐφάνη; 14 ἀργαλέων ἀνέμων = vii. 24 ἀργαλέους ἀνέμους; 16 σήματα = vii. 46; 16 οἱ δὲ ἰδόντες = vii. 42; see also on 10. These resemblances, taken singly, are slight; but their number suggests the possibility that this hymn was influenced by that to Dionysus, which is probably much older.


Commentary on line 1

a)mfi/: see on vii. 1.